| 1
| | Justin Brooks
| Pitcher | 5-10 | Jr.
| West Sand Lake, NY / Averill Park HS |
| 2
| | Erik Cabrera
| Infield | 5-7 | Jr.
| Ronkonkoma, NY / Connetquot HS |
| 3
| | Colin Barnathan
| Infield | 6-4 | Jr.
| Massapequa, NY / St. Anthony's HS |
| 4
| | P.J. Lenz
| Infield/Pitcher | 6-2 | Fr.
| Greenlawn, NY / Harborfields HS |
| 6
| | Peter Scianna
| Infield | 6-0 | So.
| Chicago, IL / St. Mary's HS |
| 7
| | Frank Intagliata
| Infield | 6-1 | Sr.
| Franklin Square, NY / Frank Carey HS |
| 8
| | Marc Rutledge
| Pitcher | 5-11 | So.
| Ridge, NY / Longwood HS |
| 9
| | Eddie Squeri
| Infield | 5-8 | Jr.
| Shirley, NY / William Floyd HS |
| 10
| | Joel Duverge
| Infield/Outfield | 6-0 | Sr.
| Brooklyn,NY / LaSalle Academy |
| 11
| | Andrew Varela
| Infield/Pitcher | 6-0 | Sr.
| Brooklyn, NY / LaSalle Academy |
| 12
| | Andrew Smith
| Pitcher | 6-1 | So.
| Sound Beach, NY / Miller Place HS |
| 13
| | Steven Morse
| Infield | 5-10 | Fr.
| Commack, NY / Commack HS |
| 15
| | Mike Courtney
| Pitcher | 6-1 | Sr.
| Bronx, NY / Salesian HS |
| 16
| | Taylor Bargiacchi
| Catcher | 5-8 | So.
| Chester, NJ / Northern Highlands HS |
| 17
| | Michael Gilroy
| Pitcher | 5-10 | Jr.
| Shoreham-Wading River, NY / Shoreham-Wading River HS |
| 18
| | Steve Shea
| Catcher | 6-2 | So.
| East Islip, NY / East Islip |
| 19
| | Chris Mendoza
| Pitcher | 5-9 | Fr.
| Ronkonkoma, NY / Connetquot HS |
| 20
| | Daniel Masiello
| Catcher | 5-6 | Fr.
| Staten Island, NY / St. Peter's HS |
| 21
| | Buddy Cipoletti
| Pitcher | 5-9 | Sr.
| West Islip, NY / St. John the Baptist |
| 22
| | Nicholas Albero
| Pitcher | 6-0 | So.
| New Rochelle, NY / New Rochelle HS |
| 23
| | Tim Comiskey
| Pitcher | 6-5 | Sr.
| Great River, NY / East Islip HS |
| 24
| | Joe Trainor
| Pitcher/Infield | 5-10 | Sr.
| Massapequa, NY / Massapequa HS |
| 25
| | Daniel Pembroke
| Infield | 6-1 | Sr.
| Shoreham-Wading River, NY / Shoreham-Wading River |
| 26
| | Gabriel Duran
| Pitcher | 5-10 | Jr.
| Brooklyn, NY / La Salle Academy |
| 27
| | Sean Craig
| Infield | 5-10 | Fr.
| Rocky Point, NY / Rocky Point HS |
| 28
| | Brian Ferguson
| Outfield | 5-10 | Jr.
| Ronkonkoma, NY / Connetquot HS |
| 29
| | Anthony De La Rosa
| Pitcher | 6-0 | So.
| Brooklyn, NY / Lasalle Academy |
| 30
| | Joe Candela
| Infield/Outfield | 5-11 | Fr.
| East Quoge, NY / Westhampton HS |
| 31
| | Ralph Tufano
| Outfield | 5-9 | Jr.
| Staten Island, NY / St. Joseph by the Sea HS |
| 32
| | Kevin Kerman
| Infield | 5-10 | Fr.
| Mastic, NY / William Floyd HS |
| RS
| | Rob Faulkner
| Pitcher/Outfield | 5-8 | Jr.
| West Islip, NY / West Islip HS |